The Thermopolis specimen of Archaeopteryx at the Wyoming Dinosaur Center. Photo by the author.
Since the time the English anatomist Richard Owen described Archaeopteryx as the “by-fossil-remains-oldest-known feathered Vertebrate” in 1863, the curious creature has been widely regarded as the earliest known bird. Lately, though, the status of the iconic animal has been up for debate. Earlier this summer, one team of paleontologists proposed that Archaeopteryx was not a bird but actually a feather-covered, non-avian dinosaur more closely related to genera like Microraptor and Troodon. Now a different team of paleontologists has published a paper in Biology Letters that says Archaeopteryx was an early bird after all.
Archaeopteryx is actually a perfect example of how new discoveries can change our perception of relationships. When the first skeleton was discovered in 1861, nothing quite like it had been found. Archaeopteryx seemed to stand by itself as the first bird. Over a century later, though, the discovery of dinosaurs such as Deinonychus, an updated understanding of dinosaurs and the eventual discovery of many, many feathered dinosaurs illustrated that Archaeopteryx exhibited a number of transitional features that illustrated how the first birds evolved directly from feathered dinosaurs.
The trouble is that Archaeopteryx appears to be so close to the emergence of the very first birds. At the moment, Archaeopteryx is most often regarded as being an archaic member of the group called the Avialae, which contains all birds (Aves) and forms more closely related to them than to other dinosaurs. What this means is that, as our understanding of what a bird actually is changes, the position of Archaeopteryx might shift. The animal might have been one of the earliest birds within the avialian group, or Archaeopteryx might have been just outside the bird group among non-avian dinosaurs. This is simply how science works and is a wonderful—if frustrating—demonstration of the fact of evolution.
